| UFC 229: Khabib vs. McGregor | Nik Lentz | 1077 →1099(+22) | Gray Maynard | 1059 →1037(-22) | Lightweight | Loss | KO |
| The Ultimate Fighter: Redemption Finale | Gray Maynard | 1040 →1059(+19) | Teruto Ishihara | 1020 →1001(-19) | Featherweight | Win | U-DEC |
| The Ultimate Fighter: Tournament of Champions Finale | Ryan Hall | 1020 →1042(+22) | Gray Maynard | 1062 →1040(-22) | Featherweight | Loss | U-DEC |
| The Ultimate Fighter: Team Joanna vs. Team Cláudia Finale | Gray Maynard | 1046 →1062(+16) | Fernando Bruno | 977 →960(-17) | Featherweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Mendes vs Lamas | Alexander Yakovlev | 968 →993(+25) | Gray Maynard | 1072 →1046(-26) | Lightweight | Loss | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Bader vs Saint Preux | Ross Pearson | 1055 →1080(+25) | Gray Maynard | 1098 →1072(-26) | Lightweight | Loss | KO |
| The Ultimate Fighter: Team Rousey vs. Team Tate Finale | Nate Diaz | 1074 →1100(+26) | Gray Maynard | 1124 →1098(-26) | Lightweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC 160: Velasquez vs Silva 2 | TJ Grant | 1094 →1120(+26) | Gray Maynard | 1151 →1124(-27) | Lightweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC on FX: Maynard vs Guida | Gray Maynard | 1134 →1151(+17) | Clay Guida | 1078 →1062(-16) | Lightweight | Win | S-DEC |
UFC 136: Edgar vs Maynard 3 | Frankie Edgar | 1147 →1171(+24) | Gray Maynard | 1158 →1134(-24) | Lightweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC 125: Resolution | Frankie Edgar | 1147 →1147 | Gray Maynard | 1158 →1158 | Lightweight | draw
draw | S-DEC |
| UFC 118: Edgar vs Penn 2 | Gray Maynard | 1137 →1158(+21) | Kenny Florian | 1158 →1137(-21) | Lightweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Maynard vs Diaz | Gray Maynard | 1119 →1137(+18) | Nate Diaz | 1076 →1059(-17) | Lightweight | Win | S-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Diaz vs Guillard | Gray Maynard | 1100 →1119(+19) | Roger Huerta | 1093 →1073(-20) | Lightweight | Win | S-DEC |
| UFC 96: Jackson vs Jardine | Gray Maynard | 1082 →1100(+18) | Jim Miller | 1045 →1027(-18) | Lightweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC 90: Silva vs Cote | Gray Maynard | 1062 →1082(+20) | Rich Clementi | 1050 →1031(-19) | Lightweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Florian vs Lauzon | Gray Maynard | 1041 →1062(+21) | Frankie Edgar | 1063 →1042(-21) | Lightweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Swick vs Burkman | Gray Maynard | 1023 →1041(+18) | Dennis Siver | 1000 →981(-19) | Lightweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Thomas vs Florian | Gray Maynard | 1000 →1023(+23) | Joe Veres | 1000 →977(-23) | Lightweight | Win | KO |
| The Ultimate Fighter: Team Pulver vs. Team Penn Finale | Gray Maynard | 1000 →1000 | Rob Emerson | 1000 →1000 | Lightweight | nc
nc | CNC |
